QUOTE (mewsical @ Apr 13 2009, 06:19 PM)

Can you give an example of Jim shutting people out permanently?
Patricia Kennealy.
QUOTE (mewsical @ Apr 13 2009, 06:19 PM)

I thought you only knew him for a few months, yet somehow you know so much more about him than anyone else in his life.
I'm amazed that
you would suggest that I know more about Jim "than anyone else in his life," especially you, who seems to know so much more about Jim and his feelings, his life and his death than I do.
Clearly, I disagree with you. I believe Kathy Lisciandro and Anne Morrison are some of the people who know more about Jim than I do
QUOTE (mewsical @ Apr 13 2009, 06:19 PM)

I'll have to disagree with passing the chore on. If you don't want to communicate with someone at all, you don't. You don't have someone else do it. You simply ignore it completely and ask your friend to stay out of it.
Everyone reacts differently to rejecting people or to being rejected. Mewsical, you might react that way, but that may not be the way someone else (Jim?) would react.
QUOTE (mewsical @ Apr 13 2009, 06:19 PM)

In the Mary and Jim scenario, there was blame on both sides. She reached out to him when she was ill and far away, and he at least reached back through Paul Ferrara. That doesn't seem like he was completely cutting her off and being cold, he was simply protecting himself from getting hurt again. He was quite vulnerable to Mary, I believe, and just didn't want to be manipulated any longer, even though I don't believe it was intentional on her part. I'm sure she was aware of his relationship with Pam by then and maybe she felt it was better to approach him through Paul, so he would not mistake her intentions.
Mewsical, in your "Mary Jim scenario," you seem to assume a great deal.
-You assume that Jim reached back through Paul. Did he? Or was it a shine it on, let Paul do it, situation?
-You believe Jim was still vulnerable to Mary? Was he? Why do you assume that?
-That he could be manipulated by Mary? Why do you assume that?
-It wasn't intentional on her part? Again, why do you assume that?
-You are sure she was aware of Jim's relationship with Pam. So are you saying Mary decided to sneak around Pam's back and get in touch with Jim through Paul?
QUOTE (mewsical @ Apr 13 2009, 06:19 PM)

She needed help and she hoped Jim would be able to help her. Indirectly, even by shrugging it off with a 'no big deal, Paul, you handle it," he did.
That wasn't the impression I got from what Diane posted of Paul's book. IMO, it didn't sound like Jim was shrugging it off. It sounded more like Jim may have said something like, "Paul, if you want to write to her, go ahead, but I'm not doing it."
Perhaps someone should ask Paul?